Skip to main content

State Vs Mann

One of the groups today in class presented a Supreme Court case called State vs Mann. The defendant John Mann shot his runaway slave, Lydia, in the back. She did end up surviving the shooting. Lydia was not owned by John Mann, she was a rented slave. North Carolina charged Mann with assault and charged 10 dollars. John believed he did not have to pay the 10 dollars, because he can do whatever he wants to his property on his owned land. The argument, also talked about how a loaned slave is still a slave with no rights and their "master" can control them however they want. The judge was then charged, because they believed that the charge was unwarrantable to the slave. The jury ended up convicting the defendant and Mann appealed the conviction. 

In my opinion, the charge and assault seemed wrong. When law comes into the picture though, Mann had the right to control a slave. This is a controversial case, because Lydia was a runaway slave and owners are allowed to punish runaways slaves however they like. The only argument though, is Lydia was technically not John Mann's property. At the time this did make sense to the government and people, but in present time this is wrong and not even fair. It is unfortunate that even injuring a human being was an unjust argument all because people of color were considered property as slaves.




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Speech Theories

The theory "Promote Tolerance" about freedom of speech and extremist speech, resonates most with me. We have the freedom to say and believe in our own opinions towards the president or government. Everyone may not agree with each other and different beliefs form, but this may better the society and our country. Beliefs that someone may have might convince another persons viewpoint into a more open idea. Lee Bollinger wrote his view  on the "Tolerant Society".  He argues that protecting it could reduce racial tensions and the beliefs of other individuals in society. Lee Bollinger also argues tolerance in favor of protecting extremist speech. Bollinger states  "toleration helps to promote a stable and open society". In support of this, he believes that it could make individuals respectful of the rights of other.  I agree with these points. Toleration can help society by encouraging respect and openness to other people's beliefs. I believe that respecting...

Gone With The Wind

In class on Friday, we watched a movie called Gone With The Wind. The movie is a historical romance and was released in 1939. This film is considered controversial that was written by Margaret Mitchell. It was also taken place during the Civil War. The theme to this  movie, is survival. " What makes some people come through catastrophes and others, apparently just as able, strong, and brave, go under? It happens in every upheaval. Some people survive; others don't", states  Mitchell.  The movie starts off with the main  character   Scarlett. She was very flirtatious and wanted to find love. The man she loved was engaged, so this was very discouraging to her. Scarlett eventually marries another man to make Ashley Wilkes jealous. During the war, many of the men in Scarlett's town were killed. She took the job as a nurse and the job seemed so overwhelming. Scarlett eventually delivered her sisters' baby too.  I can see how this movie could be offensive to...

The Help

In class we watched a movie called  The Help .  This movie is a drama film that was made in 2011. It was directed by Tate Taylor. Its setting took place in Mississippi during the 1960s. The plot, was about a group of maids who were African American. Their jobs were taking care of children and helping care for them. One of the white women in the movie begins to write a book about the bad situations that the maids have been in. The book was later published, but the maids remained anonymous.  In my opinion, it is good a book like this was written. It helps bring light into these situations that probably a lot of other African American maids go through. I understand why the maids wanted to remain anonymous, because who knows the backlash they could get. Although, I do find it inspiring that the maids did not want any credit in a book they helped create. They decided to focus on the issue and main point of the book, instead of getting fame and attention from it.  I did en...